Book Review: The Mysteries of Udolpho

The Mysteries of Udolpho by Ann RadcliffeThus had she been tossed upon the stormy sea of misfortune for the last year, with but short intervals of peace, if peace it could be called, which was only the delay of evil. (619)

So goes the year that changes Emily St. Aubert’s life. Raised in peaceful, pastoral comfort by parents who adore her, Emily’s life alters dramatically when first her mother, then her father pass away. She is given to the care of her selfish aunt who is only kind when the kindness will benefit herself. Through the actions of her aunt, Emily is removed from everything she knows – her home, her lover, her country – at the mercy of her aunt’s new husband, the Italian Montoni.

Practically every dramatic plot point possible in the history of dramatic plot points is tossed into this 693 page behemoth of a novel, written by Ann Radcliffe in 1794. Considered one of the most popular novels of Gothic literature, The Mysteries of Udolpho sports a massive cast of characters all connected by various forms of villainy. We find no less than 3 crumbling castles, 2 presumed ghosts, 1 veiled image to horrible to describe, more murderers than I can count, weeping on every page, kidnappings, sword fights, secret passages, subterranean burial chambers (which seem to only be used at midnight), shipwrecks, madness, love found and lost again, and even pirates. It’s a bit of a mess, but through the mess, I have to say I was entertained. It’s quite sensational.

Udolpho is like one of those daytime TV shows that has been on for 20 years. Every time you think that the plot is finally, FINALLY about to wrap up, a new cast of characters brings a new twist onto the scene. Out of the 693 pages, everything is described in excessive detail except the conclusion: it is really quite rushed after the abundance of earlier chapters. I suppose there is little drama to be found in “happily ever after”.

Gothic literature isn’t my thing. The mysteries, the drama, the weeping, the excessive use of commas, the word “sublime” yet again… I’m not one for horror films at all, either. Give me a Jane Austen any day! Actually, that’s why I read this – although I enjoyed Northanger Abbey, I knew there was a lot I was missing due to my unfamiliarity with the Gothic genre. Now that I’ve read Udolpho, Northanger may make its way back into my pile. I’m sure I’ll understand it better this time around.

This is my first book for Back to the Classics 2017, in the Gothic category. LINK UP here

Image result for udolpho


7 thoughts on “Book Review: The Mysteries of Udolpho

  1. Well, it looks like you had quite a slog through all those 693 pages! Good for you. How many years did it take to read… I’m glad to hear you found it entertaining. Gothic/horror literature will never take a front and center position with my reading either, but I’m glad to have dabbled in it. You prefer Jane Austen…for me, it’s Anthony Trollope. I have three of his titles selected for this year’s challenge and I’ve already read one. I’m saving the other two for later, kind of like dessert!

      • I have reviews for a number of his books on my blog. I began with the Barsetshire series but have read several of his stand alone books also. You cannot go wrong with an Anthony Trollope book! It’s guaranteed to make you smile and often laugh out loud as he makes fun of his characters, speaks directly to the reader at times, and often gives the characters names that coincide with who they are… Bishop Proudie, Dr. Filagrave, to name just two!

  2. It sounds deliciously over-the-top! I’ve been having a hard time deciding on my Gothic read so this might be the one.

    And I completely agree about Trollope, one of my favorites. His domestic novels remind me very much of my beloved Jane Austen — the lighter comic romances like Rachel Ray and Ayala’s Angel, and the Barsetshire Chronicles, more so than the political novels, though I love those too. If you get started on Trollope you may never stop as he wrote 47 novels!

  3. Oh, I totally agree. I read The Mysteries of Udolpho for the 2015 Back to the Classic challenge and also found it a slog. It was just all to much and I lost count of how many time Emily burst in to tears and composed a sonnet about nature.

Leave a Reply to JaneDoe Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s